Finesse Over Arrogance: The Pros and Cons of Lowball Offers in Real Estate

In the competitive world of real estate, making the right offer can be the difference between securing your dream home and watching it slip away. One strategy often employed by buyers is the lowball offer—proposing a price significantly below the asking amount, hoping to snag a bargain. But is this tactic effective, or does it reveal a lack of finesse in the art of negotiation?

Let’s explore the pros and cons of lowball offers, under the premise that "lowballing is for amateurs," while a more refined approach—getting an offer accepted and then negotiating—is often the better path.

The Pros of Lowball Offers

1. Potential for a Great Deal: The most obvious advantage of a lowball offer is the chance to purchase a property below market value. If the seller is motivated—perhaps under financial duress, a need to relocate quickly, or a property that has been on the market for an extended period—a lowball offer might be accepted.

2. Testing the Waters: A lowball offer can serve as a starting point in negotiations. It may prompt the seller to make a counteroffer, giving the buyer insight into the lowest price the seller is willing to accept...if you haven't insulted them or lost credibility with them by doing so; it's risky.

3. Saving Money: If successful, a lowball offer can save the buyer a significant amount of money, freeing up funds for renovations, furnishings, or other investments. To be though, this is the illusion that compels people to do this, when it's actually the exception not the rule.

The Cons of Lowball Offers

1. Risk of Offending the Seller: A lowball offer can easily be perceived as disrespectful or dismissive of the property’s value. You can look out of touch with the market. This can sour negotiations from the outset, leading the seller to reject the offer outright or become less willing to negotiate.

2. Damaging Buyer Reputation: In markets where real estate professionals and sellers communicate closely, a buyer known for making lowball offers may gain a reputation as unserious or difficult to work with, potentially harming future negotiations.

3. Missed Opportunities: A lowball offer might cause a seller to walk away from the table altogether, especially in a competitive market where other buyers are willing to pay closer to or even over the asking price. The buyer could lose the chance to secure the property they desire.

4. Wasting Time: Lowball offers can prolong the negotiation process unnecessarily. While time is spent going back and forth on price, another buyer might swoop in with a more reasonable offer, leaving the lowballer out in the cold. They may also lose their representation, as no REALTOR® worth their salt will tolerate this for too long, if at all.

Why Finesse Is Better Than Arrogance

While the allure of a lowball offer is understandable, the smarter, more sophisticated approach is to aim for acceptance first, then negotiate. Here’s why:

1. Building Trust and Rapport: An initial offer that’s within a reasonable range of the asking price is more likely to be taken seriously. It shows the seller that the buyer respects the property’s value, laying the foundation for a constructive negotiation process.

2. Keeping the Door Open: When a seller feels respected, they are more likely to be open to negotiation on other terms, such as closing dates, contingencies, or even a price reduction after inspections. Starting with a reasonable offer keeps the conversation going.

3. Securing the Property: In competitive markets, getting an offer accepted quickly is crucial. A reasonable initial offer increases the chances of acceptance, reducing the risk of another buyer stepping in.

4. Negotiating with Leverage: Once the offer is accepted, the buyer has more leverage to negotiate. For example, if the home inspection reveals issues, the buyer can negotiate for repairs or a price reduction. The seller, already emotionally invested in the sale, is more likely to concede.

In conclusion, while lowball offers may occasionally lead to a great deal, they often reflect a lack of finesse and can do more harm than good. The more effective approach is to make a reasonable offer, secure the property, and then use your REALTOR®'s negotiation skills to achieve the best possible outcome. So hire the best REALTOR® not the cheapest one. In real estate, as in life, finesse and respect will always outshine arrogance.

Image 1 by Pete Linforth from Pixabay
Image 2 by vocablitz from Pixabay
Image 3 by Pete Linforth from Pixabay
Image 4 by Tumisu from Pixabay